Spital Männedorf ZH
Pros
Lots of data on the quality of the results
Best result (1st rank) in Switzerland in the quality indicator hip replacement (artificial hip joint), reoperation
Total score from all 17 outcome-quality-indicators  
starstarstarstarstar  1.2
starstarstarstarstar  5.0
0.3%
starstarstarstarstar  4.9
0.8%
starstarstarstarstar  4.4
8.6%
starstarstarstarstar  4.3
starstarstarstarstar  3.9
7.8%
starstarstarstarstar  3.9
6.4%
starstarstarstarstar  3.1
starstarstarstarstar  3.0
starstarstarstarstar  2.6
8.7%
starstarstarstarstar  2.4
n=216 
starstarstarstarstar  2.3
starstarstarstarstar  2.0
22.4%
starstarstarstarstar  0.9
10.6%
starstarstarstarstar  0.5
44.4%
starstarstarstarstar  0.1
15%
starstarstarstarstar  0.1
12.5%
starstarstarstarstar  0.1
10.9%

starstarstarstarstar  5.0
starstarstarstarstar  5.0
276
starstarstarstarstar  4.9
starstarstarstarstar  4.9
128
starstarstarstarstar  4.9
126
starstarstarstarstar  4.8
49
starstarstarstarstar  4.7
175
starstarstarstarstar  4.7
153
starstarstarstarstar  4.7
90
starstarstarstarstar  4.5
106
starstarstarstarstar  4.5
56
starstarstarstarstar  4.5
8'090
starstarstarstarstar  4.5
55
starstarstarstarstar  4.4
58
starstarstarstarstar  4.3
267
starstarstarstarstar  4.2
82
starstarstarstarstar  4.2
76
starstarstarstarstar  4.1
69
starstarstarstarstar  3.9
48
starstarstarstarstar  3.9
13
starstarstarstarstar  3.9
113
starstarstarstarstar  3.8
35
starstarstarstarstar  3.5
9
starstarstarstarstar  3.4
52
starstarstarstarstar  3.4
10
starstarstarstarstar  3.3
4
starstarstarstarstar  3.2
100
starstarstarstarstar  2.9
60
starstarstarstarstar  2.7
1,0 
starstarstarstarstar  2.7
100
starstarstarstarstar  2.5
3,0 
starstarstarstarstar  2.5
18
starstarstarstarstar  2.2
553
starstarstarstarstar  1.8
59
starstarstarstarstar  1.2
10
starstarstarstarstar  1.1
11
starstarstarstarstar  0.5
5
starstarstarstarstar  0.3
2
starstarstarstarstar  0.1
1
starstarstarstarstar  0.1
1


Profile of the hospital 

  • Type: Big general hospital
  • Emergency department: yes
  • Intensive care unit: yes
  • Special infrastructure: CT
  • No of operating rooms: 5
  • No of delivery-rooms: 2 / C-section rate: 27% 
  • Rate of patients with supplementary insurance: 27%

About the hospital


Have you or your family member recently been treated here? (inpatient treatment)

Please share your your experiences »


Ratings from patients / visitors about the Spital Männedorf:

starstarstarstarstar
  2.8
23     /  14 

patient ratingsSource: Hospital Comparison Switzerland 14 14 patient ratings “very good” 0 0 patient ratings “good” 1 1 patient ratings “average” 2 2 patient ratings “unsatisfactory” 6 6 patient ratings “poor”

important information:
We review submitted patient reviews for compliance with our guidelines. The criteria are authenticity, appropriateness and compliance with our privacy policy. Assessments with the label «verified rating» have been confirmed by the patient with a mobile number. This gives you greater trustworthiness.

We do not offset patient ratings entered online with other quality indicators. The patient feedback therefore does not influence the scores or the ranking of the hospitals / clinics on our leaderboards. We present the feedback, which does not violate our guidelines, as we have received it. We kindly ask you to carefully consider to what extent these ratings are important for your choice of hospital.
 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Emergency room - traumatic experience for free. Incompetence, zero understanding - on the contrary - the panic and shortness of breath increased, even though I said several times what was absolutely not possible. In addition, verbal devaluation created greater panic. Every doctor in my area advises agains 
transl. from german, date of rating: 06.01.2024

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Ich hatte einen Termin in der neurologischen Abteilung dieses Krankenhauses und wurde von Dr. Estelle AmannNman untersucht. Ich war sehr enttäuscht von der Professionalität dieses Arztes. 
inpat. treatment in Aug. 2023, date of rating: 20.10.2023

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
My mother was cared for so lovingly and patiently on Ward 03 that I can only recommend this hospital to everyone! Empathy is very important here! We were also served very lovingly and professionally by Mrs. Brigitte Guetg in the coffee bar! Great compliments for the Männedorf hospital!! 
transl. from german, date of rating: 15.03.2022

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Thanks to the thorough and hearty commitment of the guest manager, Ms. Sabrina Ueltschi, I was able to change my room. I had a very restless night after the operation because of my inconsiderate roommate. Ms. S. Ueltschi clearly recognized the situation and acted immediately. Thank you! 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
Sigma resection, the operation went well (surgeon: Dr. Georg Liesch)

Spital Männedorf
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Nov. 2021, date of rating: 11.12.2021

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Highly professional hospital, very good surgery, good care and follow-up, beautiful rooms with a view, but that is not decisive for my very good reference, it is the doctors and the nursing staff 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
Gallbladder with stones removed (surgeon: Dr. Reint Burger)

Spital Männedorf
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Sep. 2021, date of rating: 06.10.2021

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Very friendly staff 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
Cruciate ligament, recovery without problems
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Mar. 2020, date of rating: 24.06.2020

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Very good 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
panniculectomia (surgeon: Dr. Merlin Guggenheim)
transl. from german, date of rating: 20.11.2019

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Very pleasant hospital. Calm. Competent staff. Great location. 
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Dec. 2018, date of rating: 12.01.2019

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Very nice staff, competent doctors! 
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Aug. 2018, date of rating: 20.09.2018

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
 
inpat. treatment in Apr. 2018, date of rating: 10.04.2018

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
Prostate reduction. One day after the surgery a second surgerywas necessary due to strong bleeding of the prostate. Now, 6 weeks after the surgery, I still have strong discomfort. Pain when draining and partial incontinence. Before the surgery I was a lot better. (surgeon: Dr. Aron Cohen)
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Nov. 2016, date of rating: 01.01.2017

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Very competent and sensitive care staff and doctors. Familial atmosphere. 
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Feb. 2016, date of rating: 11.08.2016

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Everything was perfect from entry to discharge 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
Hemorrhoid surgery with a Raffaello device. After the operation I had minimal pain and no bleeding. After 2 days I was back in the office for light work. (surgeon: Dr. Georg Liesch)
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Feb. 2022, date of rating: 01.03.2022

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Scaring patients, financial interests to the detriment of the patient 
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Aug. 2021, date of rating: 16.12.2021

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
wrong operation, then cover-up
transl. from german, date of rating: 03.12.2021

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Very empathetic, helpful and qualified employees. Applies equally to medical, nursing and non-medical personnel 
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Sep. 2021, date of rating: 27.09.2021

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
oh my god - please never again; clearly wrong diagnosis that another hospital has not subsequently confirmed in any way. Looks like they urgently want to get “something to operate” Driven by sales pressure - or boredom? Rooms are nice, nurses nice - I advise against the rest! 
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Mar. 2021, date of rating: 05.07.2021

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
I needed a total knee prosthesis ( 75 years) the position of the legs was already slightly wrong due to the previous pain. in July 2018 the surgery was carried out by Dr. J. Forberger. I am exceptionally well. Super information right from the start. 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
Total knee prosthesis, went without problems, all great, fast recovery. At home I could walk without crutches after 14 days. (surgeon: Dr. Jens Forberger)
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in Jul. 2018, date of rating: 08.04.2019

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
Patients without complimentary insurance are discharged as soon as possible. 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
prostate surgery, without problems (surgeon: Dr. Sautter)
transl. from german, date of rating: 21.11.2017

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
competent care 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
stabilisation of a forearm fracture (surgeon: Dr. Barbara Freitag )
transl. from german, inpat. treatment in May. 2017, date of rating: 07.06.2017

 unverified rating
starstarstarstarstar
The admission procedure is very chaotic and at discharge you need to leave the hospital before 10am 

About the surgery:
starstarstarstarstar
lap. Cholecystectomy, slight wound infection (surgeon: Dr. Burger)
transl. from german, date of rating: 20.03.2017

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
 
inpat. treatment in Mar. 2022, date of rating: 28.03.2022

 verified rating
starstarstarstarstar
 
inpat. treatment in Jul. 2015, date of rating: 05.11.2015


The master data for this hospital was last updated on March 31, 2024. You can find the period of origin of the quality data in the respective documentation on our portal.